Skip to main content
Notes

Why compliance certificates pass while facilities breach: auditing Consolidated EBITDA add-backs at scale

A borrower rarely submits a compliance certificate that says it is in default. Technical breaches in direct lending almost always hide inside the bridge between reported operating profit and certified Consolidated EBITDA.

By Briefed EditorialChecked 30 October 20267 min read

In middle-market direct lending and unitranche private credit, a borrower almost never delivers a quarterly compliance certificate that announces a covenant breach on its face. When leverage is tightening toward a 4.75x maintenance limit, the borrower’s finance team and sponsor naturally construct the compliance worksheet using the most generous available reading of the credit agreement.

The headline ratio on the cover page reads 4.40x. If an overstretched credit desk or an outsourced data-entry team simply keys 4.40x into a portfolio monitoring ledger, the loan stays green until the cash actually runs out two quarters later. Catching credit drift while the lender still has restructuring leverage requires auditing the arithmetic between management’s reported operating profit and the borrower’s certified Consolidated EBITDA against the exact language of the facility agreement.

Where the bridge diverges from the agreement

Across an eighty-loan direct lending book, there are eighty different definitions of Consolidated EBITDA. Even when two facilities originate from the same sponsor precedent, the negotiated schedule in Clause 1.1 (or the Definitions annex) introduces facility-specific ceilings, look-forward windows and basket interactions that change the calculation every quarter. Four failure modes account for the majority of unspotted technical breaches:

1. Percentage caps applied to the wrong base

Credit agreements routinely allow borrowers to add back pro-forma run-rate cost savings and M&A synergies expected to be realised within 12 to 18 months, subject to a percentage cap (for example, 15 per cent or 20 per cent of Consolidated EBITDA). The drafting distinction that matters is whether that 15 per cent ceiling is calculated on base EBITDA prior to pro-forma adjustments or on Consolidated EBITDA after giving effect to the add-backs. Borrowers frequently compute the cap on the inflated post-adjustment denominator, overstating covenant EBITDA by 5 to 12 per cent on a single line.

2. Shared caps and exhausted lifetime baskets

Exceptional restructuring charges, ERP implementation costs and site closure expenses are often governed by either a shared aggregate cap alongside run-rate synergies or a cumulative lifetime basket over the life of the facility. Auditing Q3 compliance requires knowing how much of that lifetime basket was already consumed in Q1 and Q2, and whether Amendment No. 1 reset or froze the allowance. Point-in-time document review tools that only look at the Q3 upload miss cumulative basket exhaustion entirely.

3. Run-rate realisation windows that have expired

When a borrower acquires a bolt-on subsidiary in Q4 of the prior year and claims £2.5m of projected 12-month run-rate synergies, each subsequent quarter must be checked to ensure the same cost savings are not being double-counted in both actual operating results and the remaining pro-forma add-back line, and that unachieved synergies drop out of the bridge once the 12-month window closes.

4. Omitted ancillary debt and springing liquidity definitions

Covenant errors extend to the numerator as well. Borrowers frequently report Senior Net Debt using principal term debt less total cash on the balance sheet. Yet the credit agreement’s definition of Total Net Debt may require including drawn standby letters of credit above a de minimis threshold, earn-out liabilities that have crystallised, or finance leases, while restricting trapped foreign cash from being netted against debt.

Why manual checks fail during the quarter-end fortnight

Every credit officer knows how to check these clauses on a single deal. The problem is calendar compression. Eighty borrowers report within the same ten-day window forty-five days after quarter end. Checking one borrower’s management pack and compliance worksheet against a 250-page credit agreement, two side letters and four prior quarters of basket usage takes an experienced associate three to four hours.

Multiply that across eighty facilities and the desk faces more than 300 hours of mechanical forensic verification right when active deal diligence is competing for the same people. Under that pressure, associates check the watchlist credits closely and skim the rest. The credit that is quietly slipping from performing to stressed is the one that gets skimmed.

How Briefed automates clause-pinned covenant verification

Briefed for Private Credit replaces quarter-end skimming with deterministic, clause-pinned verification across the entire book:

  • One-time facility rule extraction: When a loan closes (or is onboarded), Anya reads the executed credit agreement and extracts every financial covenant, Consolidated EBITDA definition, add-back cap, lifetime basket, step-down schedule and equity cure window into a structured loan record, with each rule pinned to its exact clause and page.
  • Automatic spreading on arrival: When the borrower’s quarterly PDF pack and Excel certificate land, Briefed spreads the accounts and maps every bridge item to the facility’s specific definitions.
  • Line-by-line discrepancy audit: Briefed recomputes Consolidated EBITDA and Net Debt independently of the borrower’s worksheet, enforces prior-quarter basket consumption and flags every variance with a one-click link to the offending clause.

Instead of spending two weeks re-keying numbers into Allvue or S&P iLevel, or waiting a week on an offshore Oxane queue, the credit committee starts Monday morning with a ranked exception queue showing which borrowers actually breached or compressed their cushions.

Media

Independent financial journalism

Live market reporting, weekday and Sunday editions, a searchable archive and the editorial standards behind every story.